Since the upgrade to direct fills, the category hints for my investment accounts seems to behave differently. Where before it did a pretty solid job of differentiating investment income from securities transactions, it now appears to categorize everything as security transactions. I use this hint to categorize my activities in these accounts via AutoCat. Anyone else seeing this? Is there a root cause?
Based on what Heather mentioned about that row when i added it it comes from the aggregator/bank. I wonder if switching to direct fill switched the aggregator and field provided. Or if it’s a completely different thing now. But do yo use that field a lot? I used to but once i have autocat set up for like 70% of the stuff it doesn’t take much time to manually add as i review the transactions and tag certain lines
Thanks. I do use them a fair amount for differentiating stock transactions from dividend income. I am working with the support team to try to understand what changed and see if there is a workaround.
I just looked at my investment spreadsheet. I don’t do much with it but let all the transactions sit there. The category hints for dividends are listed as income and reinvestments are securities trading. There are others, but I am not sure if sharing will help; I don’t really understand all of that, so right now I am just gathering the information for when I want to sit and research all the meanings. In the mean time, if there is another type of transaction you are comparing with, I can see if I have it and share the information.
Thanks! Since my update to direct fills, my investment transactions have all been coming in as security transactions rather than investment income. Despite know some of them were dividend income.
Interesting you are still seeing both. I am on Yodlee. Do you know which aggregator you are using?
I have yodlee for my investment accounts. I’ve been using direct fills since the beginning of the year. The accounts are at Fidelity and Wealthfront.
Ok. Good to know it is still working for you. My account is with Schwab. The AI assistant said the aggregators responsible for the category hints. We will see what the human support team can turn up.
I am pretty suspicious this is down to the direct fills changes, but I guess it’s possible Schwab changed something on their end.
when the transactions comes in, how are the details, it would be helpful if you could give us a couple examples. because for say Merrill, it does differentiate but only by a few chars, which to be fair is rather annoying
THanks. The human team has concluded their investigation, and they are saying the hints come from the institution. So Schwab must have changed something on their side.
I have reviewed the details carefully, and there’s nothing there that would allow an AutoCat trigger to do the right thing, at least not perfectly. I could use the polarity on the amount to get closer, and maybe I will pursue that.
I get a fair amount of these transactions monthly, but they are mostly easy to spot and do by hand, since I am on Tiller most every day. If I leave them uncategorized by AutoCat, they will show up blank, which will help them stand out.
Thanks everyone for the suggestions. I am going to move on from this for now.