šŸ† Investment Returns (Monthly, Annual, Total, XIRR)!

Some of you have had issues with the load time so I rearchitected the workbook and optimized it quite a bit. I am seeing the time between loading from scratch to completing the calculations improve by 35-40% vs the previous Rev.

Link to Rev 2.0 can be found in the first introductory post.

I also added some new features and tweaked how to set it up. Details can be found in the first introductory post.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Thank you.

1 Like

Brand new Tiller user trying this out, it looks great. FYI that the URL import didn’t work, the Tiller Connection tab showed a Ref error about in-cell images in the Transactions and Balance History cells:

I realized that the Tiller Foundational Spreadsheet includes ā€˜T’ logos in the respective A1 cells of Transactions and Balance History (normally hidden). Perhaps that’s something they changed recently?

When I manually removed the embedded images from the Foundation sheet most of the errors went away. I’m still seeing errors for Tags and Groups. I don’t see those columns in the Tiller Foundation Template ā€œTransactionsā€ tab. The only reference to Groups is on the Account tab. A global search for ā€œtagsā€ turned up nothing.

As a new user, it only lets me post one screenshot at a time. Will share more in a separate thread if it lets me.

The offending ā€˜T’ logo

@btrombley - First off, welcome to Tiller.

I have not see that error and my Balance History has this logo as well…

The formula in A1 is…
image

Also, my Transactions sheet has ā€œGroupā€ (Column G) and ā€œTagsā€ (Column L)…

I have been using Tiller for multiple years and I believe those 2 columns were there when I started. However, the workbook doesn’t use category Groups or Tags so it should not affect its functionality at all.

Let me know if you have any additional questions.

The image formulas cause external reference warnings (for awhile) now and so new templates have replaced them by inserting the image in the cell instead. You may be able to reproduce the issue by doing the same :thinking:

@Mark.S

Interesting. As I mentioned, my Balance History has Image formula and I don’t get an error when I do an ImportRange. Based on what @btrombley said, the image in the cell, cause the error, NOT the image formula.

Yep, and so you could maybe reproduce the error condition and make a change so that new template users do not run into the same issue.

@Mark.S
Thanks. Misunderstood your initial point.

I have updated the workbook to account for when there is an in-cell image in the ImportRange range. Here is the link to v2.1.

I’ll also add it to the top of this post.

1 Like

Hi Cowboy13, sounds like a great sheet. Is there an excel version available?
Thanks, Jon.

No Excel version and I don’t have the Excel experience to create one.

This is a great sheet. Thank you!

A couple notes.

  1. Account names matter. A few of my accounts had apostrophes (eg. Steve’s Roth). Those accounts would not acquire any balances in this sheet, ony cashflow, similar to clkincaid’s experience above. I removed all punctuation from account titles and it fixed the problem.
  2. Its probably obvious to others, but you need to have a pretty clean balance history and transactions tab. The names of some of my accounts have somewhat migrated over the years. I cleaned up the tabs so that account names were systematic. Also deleted a bunch of errors ($0 balances and duplicates) which could foul things up.
  3. I would love more than 15 accounts. I find tiller useful because i’ve accumulated a number of accounts from several jobs over the years. Is there a simple way for me to increase the number of accounts? I understand that the number of columns in Set Up and Calcs will explode…

I was able to add a bunch of columns and now all my accounts tracked.

Thanks again, this is very useful.

@folkhero - First off, welcome to the Tiller community!

You are absolutely correct that you need clean Account Balance and Transactions histories for this to work properly. This is true for any analysis you want to do that goes back multiple years.

As for >15 accounts, it can be done, but the workbook is already a calculation hog and for every account you add, it adds a lot of columns (I did the analysis a while ago, but can’t remember the exact number).

I had read a while ago about potential issues with apostrophes in account names so I don’t have any.

I thought about using account numbers but you will the run into issue when your bank or investment firm gets acquired and changes the account number. Since account names are controlled by the user, you can always edit them to be consistent and pull in a longer timeframe history.

Let me know if you have any other questions.

@Cowboy13

I have it running now with 28 accounts. Some are inactive, and only have historical data. Some are retirement accounts that I haven’t rolled over. Anyway, 556 columns in Set up and Calcs. I have 3 groups, so many columns are empty. Only a few years data in the sheet so I don’t know if it would bog down with more history. I guess I’ll see how it holds up with time.

I don’t plan to run it very often. Maybe once a month. So it doesn’t bother me if it takes a minute or two.

I’ve been looking for a tool like this for a long time. I’m really glad you put it together and take the time to support it. Thanks again.

@Cowboy13,

Looking throuh setup and calcs, it looks like returns from comparison tickers don’t account for dividends, is that correct?

No it does not, simply the price of the ticker from Google Finance.

I looked for a way for a while but I could not find an easy way that was also free.

Thanks I figured. Without dividends its not that useful to me so I’ll probably work on a way to delete those cells and graphics to simplify the sheet a bit.